- Soaps
- News
Soap Alum-Turned-Hallmark Star Rushes to Find a Killer as a Body Turns up on the Beach — and a Mysterious Bank Deposit Connects a Close Friend to the Crime
Thursday, May 13th, 2021
Death, money and suspicion go hand-in-hand in the latest island investigation.
In February, former Passions star Jesse Metcalfe (Miguel) revealed that he and his Hallmark Movies & Mysteries co-star Sarah Lind had wrapped the latest movie in their series. We are excited to announce that the duo will be back on your screens in Poisoned in Paradise: A Martha’s Vineyard Mystery on Sunday, May 16, at 8:00 pm!
So, what has retired detective Jeff Jackson and Dr. Zee Madieras chasing clues around the island this time? When a local waitress turns up dead on the beach, a mysterious deposit suddenly appears in Zee’s bank account. Let’s just say, Martha’s Vineyard once again will prove to be anything but the simple, scenic life Jeff was seeking.
More: Jesse Metcalfe exits Hallmark’s Chesapeake Shores
As a matter of fact, someone proves that point to Jeff in the movie’s promo and admits, “I got involved in something I shouldn’t have.” Good thing Chief Madieras is there to offer Jeff a little relief, to which he gladly accepts with a sigh, “I thought you’d never ask.” Watch for yourself…
Now that we have some details on the movie’s backstory, how about a game of cat and mouse? The network shared a video of Metcalfe, who reached out to fans by saying, “Let’s play a little game, shall we?” The actor revealed three objects in relation to what happened to the murder victim in the upcoming movie then invited us all to help solve the mystery. “Time to pick your poison,” he gave the go-ahead but warned, “Choose wisely.”
Do you think you picked the right poison? We’ll just have to wait and see when the storyline plays out this weekend!
We’ve ranked Metcalfe as one of our 20 most beloved Hallmark actors. View the other 19 in our photo gallery below then leave your favorites in the comment section.
Get more Hallmark news — and your free daily soap-opera fix — delivered straight to your email inbox by signing up for Soaps.com’s newsletter.
Video: Hallmark Movies and Mysteries/YouTube
Image: ©2019 Crown Media United States LLC/Photographer: Ricardo Hubbs
1/20
<p>Brendan Penny wooed viewers when his character Kevin O’Brien returned from the military on Hallmark’s <em>Chesapeake Shores</em>. Though the series has come to an end, it’s always a treat when fans get to see him shine in new original movies, as well as the network’s <em>In the Vineyard</em> features.</p>
Image: Jill Johnson/JPI
2/20
<p>What can we say about Niall Matter? He takes part in many of the Hallmark special movie events: Valentine’s Day, Fall Harvest, <a href="https://soaps.sheknows.com/soaps/news/572183/hallmarks-countdown-to-christmas-2020/" target="_blank">Countdown to Christmas</a> and even starred opposite Candace Cameron Bure in the <em>Aurora Teagarden Mysteries</em>.</p>
Image: ©2019 Crown Media United States LLC/David Strongman
3/20
<p>Among Ashley Williams’ many talents is her ability to make viewers laugh with her quirky taglines while pulling on their heartstrings, like in the <em>Christmas in Evergreen</em> movies. No matter what movie she stars in, she incorporates her unique talent into each character yet is able to separate each story as its own. </p>
Image: Jill Johnson/JPI
4/20
<p>Nikki DeLoach may be familiar to daytime viewers for her two year stint on <em>Days of Our Lives</em> as Brenda. When it comes to Hallmark, she has no problem taking on a strong female lead while allowing the emotions of her character’s dilemma to draw viewers into the main focus of the story. One of her best to date was <em>Love Takes Flight</em>, as a woman in charge of an entire hospital yet not fully in charge of her heart. </p>
Image: ©2019 Crown Media United States LLC/Photographer: Alan Zenuk
5/20
<p>Jack Wagner may be best known to daytimers for his stints as <em>Bold & Beautiful</em>‘s Nick and <em>General Hospital’</em>s Frisco. But on Hallmark, he’s beloved for his role as Bill Avery in <em>When Calls the Heart</em>. And when the network cast him opposite Josie Bissett in its <em>Wedding March</em> movies, it was like we were right back at <em>Melrose Place</em>, where he played Peter opposite her Jane. </p>
Image: ©2018 Crown Media United States LLC/Allister Foster
6/20
<p>Taylor Cole is always a pleasure to watch and became such a hit with Hallmark fans that she was given her own mystery series, <em>Ruby Herring Mysteries</em>. And here’s a fun fact: She’s also the <a href="https://soaps.sheknows.com/days-of-our-lives/news/569530/days-of-our-lives-shawn-christian-daughter-taylor-cole-wedding/" target="_blank">stepdaughter of <em>Days of Our Lives’</em> Shawn Christian</a>. </p>
Image: Jill Johnson/JPI
7/20
<p>Sam Page is another actor who can fit into many characters. He can play an ex-boyfriend, as in <em><a href="https://soaps.sheknows.com/days-of-our-lives/news/578916/hallmark-movies-mysteries-miracles-of-christmas-schedule-2020/" target="_blank">A Godwink Christmas: Second Chance, First Love</a></em>, or a prince — and we can always count on his cute dimples. And before he was a Hallmark hottie, he played Trey Shepard on <em>All My Children</em>.</p>
Image: ©2019 Crown Media United States LLC/Photographer: Ricardo Hubbs
8/20
<p>This hunk’s dark hair and blue eyes first garnered the attention of daytime viewers when he played Miguel Lopez-Fitzgerald on <em>Passions</em>. Not only did we get to see him in various Hallmark movies, he was a main player in <em>Chesapeake Shores</em> as well as the series <em>A Martha’s Vineyard Mystery</em>.</p>
Image: Jill Johnson/JPI
9/20
<p>Jill Wagner started out as a co-host for the game show series <em>Wipe-Out</em> and was part of the crew of MTV’s <em>Punk’d</em>. Her aptitude for comedy spills into each character she plays, so it’s no surprise that she’s on Hallmark’s go-to list of stars. Not only has she appeared in some of their most popular movies, but she headlines the series, <em>Mystery 101</em>. </p>
Image: ©2020 Crown Media United States LLC/Brownie Harris
10/20
<p>Trevor Donovan played <em>Days of Our Lives’</em> Jeremy Horton before making his way to Hallmark. One of our favorite roles was seeing him play a Lieutenant in the U.S. Navy in the flick <a href="https://soaps.sheknows.com/days-of-our-lives/news/574825/days-of-our-lives-jen-lilley-hallmark-christmas-movie-2020/" target="_blank"><em>USS Christmas</em></a>, opposite fellow former Salemite Jen Lilley (ex-Theresa). Sure, his character started off more Grinch than gregarious, but we all knew his heart would grow at least three sizes before the final reel unspooled.<br /> </p>
Image: ©2020 Crown Media United States LLC/Eric Zachanowich
11/20
<p>If Hynes’ characters have one thing in common, it’s probably that they tend to be more on the soft-spoken side. However, by the end of each story, such as <em>Winter in Vail</em> or <em>On the 12th Date of Christmas</em>, he leaves us shouting for more. </p>
Image: Hallmark
12/20
<p><em>General Hospital</em>‘s loss was definitely Hallmark’s gain. Fans were still mourning the death of his daytime alter ego — good-guy Nathan — when along came <em>Unleashing Mr. Darcy.</em> Such a hit was that Hallmark feature that it garnered a sequel and Paevey — thanks in part to offerings like <a href="https://soaps.sheknows.com/general-hospital/news/583737/general-hospital-ryan-paevey-hallmark-home-family-timeless-christmas/" target="_blank"><em>A Timeless Christmas</em></a> — became one of their go-to good guys.</p>
Image: Jill Johnson/JPI
13/20
<p>Sweeney’s Sami may be one of <em>Days of Our Lives</em>‘ most notorious bad girls, but she’s proven just how versatile she really is since joining the Hallmark family. Between troublemaking stints in Salem, the actress is kept busy by her numrous Hallmark projects, including two movie series, <em>Murder She Baked</em> and <a href="https://soaps.sheknows.com/days-of-our-lives/news/581967/days-of-our-lives-kristian-alfonso-chronicle-mysteries-cast/" target="_blank"><em>Chronicle Mysteries</em></a>.</p>
Image: Jill Johnson/JPI
14/20
<p>Look up the words “tall, dark and handsome” in the dictionary and you’re going to find Webster’s picture. Having gotten his start playing Roger on <em>Sunset Beach</em> and Nicholas on <em>Days of Our Lives</em>, the guy knows his way around a soapy story. His Hallmark characters tend to have a take-charge attitude, as evidenced in the series <a href="https://soaps.sheknows.com/soaps/news/561970/soap-alums-hallmark-movies-mysteries-signature-series-premieres/" target="_blank"><em>Matchmaker Mysteries</em></a>. </p>
Image: ©2019 Crown Media United States LLC/Farah Nosh
15/20
<p>On <em>Guiding Light, </em>Lenz won hearts as young heroine Michelle. And after appearing in several Hallmark projects, it was <em>Bottled With Love</em>, in which she appeared opposite Andrew Walker, that really made her a staple on the netowrk. She’s usually cast as the girl next door who is everything we want to be… especially when she gets the guy by story’s end! </p>
Image: Jill Johnson/JPI
16/20
<p>Danica McKellar first stole hearts playing Winnie on <em>The Wonder Years</em>. And though she’s now a wife and mother, we can still see a glimpse of that sweet teenage persona incorporated in some of her Hallmark roles, including the part of super sleuth Angie Dove in the <em>Matchmaker Mysteries </em>movies.</p>
Image: Hallmark
17/20
<p>Fans loved to watch <em>Days of Our Lives’</em> Lilley tear up Salem as bad girl Theresa. However, when it comes to Hallmark movies like <em>Angel Falls: A Novel Holiday</em>, we come to see her play the good girl with a heart of gold. It’s a role she plays well, making her one of the most popular Hallmark heroines out there. </p>
Image: ©2019 Crown Media United States LLC/Ricardo Hubbs
18/20
<p>Mention Hallmark movies to a fan of the genre, and it’s likely they’ll immediately summon up an image of Bure. One of the most popular actresses on the network, she keeps us entertained no matter what the season, plus has her own mystery series, <em>Aurora Teagarden Mysteries</em>. </p>
Image: ©2018 Crown Media United States LLC/Photographer: Allister Foster
19/20
<p>She was just a little girl when first she played <em>All My Children</em>‘s Bianca — daughter of the iconic Erica Kane — but she’s sense grown into a lovely leading lady. From wholesome holiday movies like <em>Time for Us to Come Home for Christmas</em> to the addictive <em>Crossword Mysteries </em>series, she’s one of Hallmark’s most recognizable faces. </p>
Image: ©2020 Crown Media United States LLC/Fred Hayes
20/20
