Josh Casaubon (ABC)

None of us will ever forgot Llanview’s sexy Assistant District Attorney – or the day One Life to Live’s Josh Casaubon (ex-Hugh Hughes) left the show. Although fans were led to believe that Hugh was the man underneath the bandages, lying in pain in that hospital bed back in October of 2006, we mourned his death after the truth came out surrounding the mistaken identity, which in fact proved that Hugh had died – and that John McBain (Michael Easton) was the bound up man left with the scars.