I was hoping eric would say well quinn you kissed ridge too while ridge was with brooke and you(quinn) was with me.
I love Quinn, but I do not like how she sounds like such a huge hypocrite right now. She told Eric that Brooke was making out in secret with a man that dumped his son out of a helicopter, which is true but she is completely glossing over the fact that her best friend a member of the kidnappers club was making out with Ridge in secret. I love seeing Quinn front and center, I love that she called Brooke out, but I hate that she is being a hypocrite . I know they all are but usually it’s with stuff that is far in the past not something so recent. She cannot excuse Ridge and Shauna while vilifying Brooke. Either all are wrong or none are. It would be better if she went after Brooke because Brooke went after her first . That would be a lot more fun to watch.
I don’t think Eric has much room to talk considering his relationship first with Katie, then with Sheila while with Quinn but this is about Brooke betraying her husband and her sister yet again while Eric had everyone rallying around Brooke and Ridge to the point of kicking Quinn’s best friend out of the pool house. I haven’t seen the last couple of episodes yet but I hope Eric apologized for that.
I don’t think anyone has forgotten Shauna and Ridge were kissing. It’s the reason Brooke slapped Shauna, declared war on Quinn, then Eric kicked Shauna to the curb because of it. I think there’s a huge difference between Shauna making out with Ridge and Brooke making out Bill. This is the third time Brooke has betrayed her sister with Bill. Even trying to convince Eric to say Bill’s baby was his.
Agreed, in my opinion the two scenarios are completely different. Don’t get me wrong, I believe Ridge kissing Shauna was wrong too, but (again in my opinion), Brooke and Bill kissing was way worse due to the continued betrayal of her sister. Personally I wouldn’t have taken Bill back or forgiven Brooke if I were Katie. I wish she didn’t miscarry Bill’s baby, then Katie could have had that reminder of that disgusting betrayal. Then again knowing the writing she probably would have forgiven Brooke, look at Bridget forgiving Brooke.
If this was about what Brooke did to her sister I would completely agree with you, but in regards to Ridge what she did was not even close to what Ridge did. Ridge had a whole relationship with Shauna, an emotional and physical connection. Quinn keeps saying what Brooke did to Ridge was worse, and as much as I love Quinn, I think in that respect she’s wrong. This isn’t about Katie for anyone, it’s about Ridge.
I think they are all a bunch of hypocrites.
Brooke kissed Ridge’s worse enemy. To me it’s the same as when Caroline made out with Ridge while married to Rick. Rick said if it had been anyone but Ridge. Well that’s the same thing with Ridge, had it been anyone but Bill. She knew Ridge would probably not forgive her for kissing Bill again but rather than push him away, she kissed him.
We know Brooke knows how to push a man away. Look what she did to Ridge’s son, over the cliff he went. But when it’s Ridge’s enemy who should be shoved she puckers up that mouth of hers and gets right into it, gives him what he wants.
Ridge made out with one of Brooke’s worst enemies, he not only made out with her he had a relationship with her. One that was so deep he was able to go running to her when he got angry with Brooke. Brooke felt the same way about every member of the kidnappers club that Ridge felt about Bill. Ridge continuously moves the goal post so he can excuse himself or actions while simultaneously blaming Brooke for the same exact behavior. I personally think it is ridiculous for Brooke to be angry about Ridge and Shauna just like it is ridiculous for Ridge to be angry about Brooke and Bill. They broke up and kissed someone else , it’s not a big deal. The only injured party here is Katie.
We are right on the money in every post in this thread. Well said!
I didn’t realize Brooke and Shauna had a history comparable to that of Ridge and Bill.
I’m not really concerned about that anyway. I don’t care who’s worse Brooke or Ridge.
I’m concerned about Eric and Quinn. I’m not too happy with the way Eric has treated his wife in all this. I think Eric owes Quinn an apology for kicking her friend out of the guest house.
Actually Eric owes Quinn more than an apology. He owes her a romantic trip to the destination of her choice.
There’s not a history comparable. It’s not comparable (in my opinion).
Completely agree 100%! Eric needs to learn to treat his wife better. I’m sorry but he should not be taking his ex wife’s side over his current wife’s side. That’s completely inappropriate in my opinion.
Ita. Shauna is guilty of trying to protect her daughter from jail. Brooke is guilty of the exact same thing. Brooke told Hope she’s a chemist so she knows there’s no trace of Thomas’s body in that vat. As long as Hope keeps her mouth shut she can get away with killing Thomas.
When it comes to kissing other women’s men, nobody’s got anything on Brooke.
And yes ITA Eric needs to be loyal to and supportive of his own wife not his ex-wife.
Shauna’s daughter kidnapped Brooke’s granddaughter and when Shauna found out she worked to conceal the crime. Brooke expressed numerous times to Ridge how she felt about every member of the kidnappers club including Shauna. I don’t think they need to make a list and compare how much they each hate Bill and Shauna and why, seems to me that they both hate them so Ridge cannot have Shauna as a make out buddy and then cry about Brooke kissing his enemy one time.
Eric, in my opinion, has not treated Quinn well for a long time. He took Pam’s side over her and seems to be taking Brooke’s side now. At first I really liked Quinn and Eric together, they were an unexpected couple and he stood up against every member of his family to be with her, I don’t see that same devotion that was once there.
Not Quinn’s fault Eric is a fool for clearly not looking.
She was right about Pam and now she is right about Brooke. She was also right about Sally.
If Eric wants to live in denial, that is his problem
I agree. She tells him a lot of truths that he doesn’t want to see.
Ridge expressed many times how he felt about rick after his role in phoebes death and going after his other daughter brooke didnot care that ridge feared for steffys safety he didnit hand back his rings to brooke or tell her to choose
But brooke expected ridge to turn in his son for her daughter
Eric is a joke quin needs to make his pockets hurt
Ridge can indeed have Shauna as a make out buddy then complain about Brooke making out with Bill because that’s exactly what Ridge is doing. Not only is he doing it but he’s doing it in Vegas.
Shauna’s only crime is covering up for her daughter. Maybe Ridge remembers Brooke doing the same thing, covering up for her daughter thinking she killed his son by shoving him into a vat of acid.
It would be nice if Quinn could convince Eric that Brooke doesn’t belong in the Forrester family and that he should stop trying to reconcile Ridge and Brooke but I won’t be holding my breath.
Bottomline Brooke took her ring off and tried to make him chose between her and his son. According to Brooke rules once the ring came off Ridge was fair game but he wasn’t. Brooke has two standards
One for her and one for everyone else. This is most definitely about Brooke betraying Katie once again. Shauna don’t owe Brooke anything but Brooke should care about her sister not to go there again. Ridge has his faults but he’s not the problem Brooke is the problem.