As Johnny begs Carly for forgiveness this week, she finally asks him the one question some have been dying for her to ask from the beginning. Why didn’t he fake sleeping with Kate to make Sonny mad? Why did he actually go through with it? As he scrambled for an answer, we had to wonder if there was a chance Carly might actually take him back.

What do you think? Answer by taking our poll below and don’t forget to check out the latest General Hospital Weekly Blog.