Credit: Howard Wise, Sean Smith/JPI; Peacock; Walt Disney Television
Jacqueline MacInnes Wood
Jacqueline MacInnes Wood’s character on The Bold and the Beautiful always manages to get herself in a pickle but one thing’s for sure, Steffy knows her way around Forrester Creations. The actress would be a perfect fit cast as a strong woman in the business world on Hallmark.
Calling doctor love! Tanner Novlan’s Dr. Finn on The Bold and the Beautiful not only shows every patient — even Thomas Forrester! — the same level of care, his sweet demeanor is very hard to resist. Sure, he could jump into a Hallmark movie as a new small town doctor, but with a smile like his, he could play just about any character — even a patient in need.
Robert Scott Wilson
Robert Scott Wilson may be a reformed serial killer on Days of Our Lives but Ben’s transformation from the Necktie Killer to a grieving groom, who now looks out for others, has been a hard pill to swallow for many. However, serial killers aren’t heroes on Hallmark — but what female lead wouldn’t simply melt following a marriage proposal from this guy?!
From sweet Brady to bad-ass biker chic, Victoria Konefal has lit Days of Our Lives on fire — and as Ciara has found herself in the middle of one as well! We can picture her now on Hallmark… as the daughter of an uptight mayor returning home — not with a law degree but with a license to ride! Yes, a woman owning and operating a new motorcycle shop in town would be fun.
We can’t deny that Katelyn MacMullen’s Willow made a beautiful bride on General Hospital — even though it started out as a marriage of convenience. June on Hallmark makes for a romantic month filled with weddings and MacMullen could easily be any handsome prince’s happily ever after.
While General Hospital’s Josh Swickard could play any number of leads on the Hallmark Channel, we’ve witnessed his character Chase firsthand as a sexy cop. Why not give him his own series on Hallmark Movies & Mysteries? Cop, robber, whatever, Swickard’s another actor who could do it all.
Sofia Mattsson’s Sasha rocked a Captain Marvel costume during Halloween on General Hospital in 2019. Picture this… a single dad moves to a small town, next door to a local beauty who happens to be an elementary teacher. In steps said beauty, dressed for Halloween, wins over the kids and ultimately their father’s heart.
Mishael Morgan’s Hilary and Amanda on The Young and the Restless lived two different lives as twins separated at birth. Taking a page from Candace Cameron Bure’s Switched for Christmas, Morgan could play twins on Hallmark — one a world renowned supermodel and the other who stayed behind. Craving the other’s life, they switch places, unbeknownst to those around them.
Bryton James’ Devon may have inherited his billionaire status on The Young and the Restless — unlike Victor who was self-made. James could reverse the roles on Hallmark with a hometown-boy-done-good, who saves a local school from being closed or rescues a down-on-her-luck damsel from losing her family farm just in time for Christmas.
We won’t argue that Mark Grossman’s The Young and the Restless character is total opposite of a Hallmark leading man. However, a bad boy with a heart is very appealing to many women, and with Grossman’s good looks we have no doubt that he could win the heart of even the most reserved female.