Credit: Howard Wise, Sean Smith/JPI; Peacock; Walt Disney Television
Jacqueline MacInnes Wood
Image Credit: Howard Wise/JPI
Jacqueline MacInnes Wood’s character on The Bold and the Beautiful always manages to get herself in a pickle but one thing’s for sure, Steffy knows her way around Forrester Creations. The actress would be a perfect fit cast as a strong woman in the business world on Hallmark.
Tanner Novlan
Image Credit: Howard Wise/JPI
Calling doctor love! Tanner Novlan’s Dr. Finn on The Bold and the Beautiful not only shows every patient — even Thomas Forrester! — the same level of care, his sweet demeanor is very hard to resist. Sure, he could jump into a Hallmark movie as a new small town doctor, but with a smile like his, he could play just about any character — even a patient in need.
Robert Scott Wilson
Image Credit: Jill Johnson/JPI
Robert Scott Wilson may be a reformed serial killer on Days of Our Lives but Ben’s transformation from the Necktie Killer to a grieving groom, who now looks out for others, has been a hard pill to swallow for many. However, serial killers aren’t heroes on Hallmark — but what female lead wouldn’t simply melt following a marriage proposal from this guy?!
Victoria Konefal
Image Credit: Jill Johnson/JPI
From sweet Brady to bad-ass biker chic, Victoria Konefal has lit Days of Our Lives on fire — and as Ciara has found herself in the middle of one as well! We can picture her now on Hallmark… as the daughter of an uptight mayor returning home — not with a law degree but with a license to ride! Yes, a woman owning and operating a new motorcycle shop in town would be fun.
Katelyn MacMullen
Image Credit: Howard Wise/JPI
We can’t deny that Katelyn MacMullen’s Willow made a beautiful bride on General Hospital — even though it started out as a marriage of convenience. June on Hallmark makes for a romantic month filled with weddings and MacMullen could easily be any handsome prince’s happily ever after.
Josh Swickard
Image Credit: Howard Wise/JPI
While General Hospital’s Josh Swickard could play any number of leads on the Hallmark Channel, we’ve witnessed his character Chase firsthand as a sexy cop. Why not give him his own series on Hallmark Movies & Mysteries? Cop, robber, whatever, Swickard’s another actor who could do it all.
Sofia Mattsson
Image Credit: Howard Wise/JPI
Sofia Mattsson’s Sasha rocked a Captain Marvel costume during Halloween on General Hospital in 2019. Picture this… a single dad moves to a small town, next door to a local beauty who happens to be an elementary teacher. In steps said beauty, dressed for Halloween, wins over the kids and ultimately their father’s heart.
Mishael Morgan
Image Credit: Howard Wise/JPI
Mishael Morgan’s Hilary and Amanda on The Young and the Restless lived two different lives as twins separated at birth. Taking a page from Candace Cameron Bure’s Switched for Christmas, Morgan could play twins on Hallmark — one a world renowned supermodel and the other who stayed behind. Craving the other’s life, they switch places, unbeknownst to those around them.
Bryton James
Image Credit: Howard Wise/JPI
Bryton James’ Devon may have inherited his billionaire status on The Young and the Restless — unlike Victor who was self-made. James could reverse the roles on Hallmark with a hometown-boy-done-good, who saves a local school from being closed or rescues a down-on-her-luck damsel from losing her family farm just in time for Christmas.
Mark Grossman
Image Credit: Howard Wise/JPI
We won’t argue that Mark Grossman’s The Young and the Restless character is total opposite of a Hallmark leading man. However, a bad boy with a heart is very appealing to many women, and with Grossman’s good looks we have no doubt that he could win the heart of even the most reserved female.