Credit: Jill Johnson/JPI (2), John Paschal/JPI, George De Sota/JPI
Kathryn Hays
Image Credit: Courtesy of the Everett Collection
Though As the World Turns often orbited around drama magnet Kim Hughes during her late portrayer’s jaw-dropping 1972-2010 run in the role, the actress was never in the running for the Daytime Emmy that she so richly deserved. One word: Why?
Tuc Watkins
Image Credit: George De Sota/JPI
As One Life to Live’s mischievous David Vickers, the funnyman with the matinee-idol face never met a scene that he couldn’t steal. Nonetheless, he was overlooked time and again (and again and again!) for a Daytime Emmy nomination. Perplexing!
Judith Chapman
Image Credit: Howard Wise/JPI (3)
In her nearly 50-year career, daytime’s Bette Davis has stunned on everything from General Hospital (as Ginny Blake) to Young & Restless (as Gloria Last-Name-Unecessary). Even more stunning? Her fantabulous body of work has never been recognized. W the actual F?
Emily McLaughlin
Image Credit: ABC
From 1963-91, the original General Hospital cast member filled our prescriptions for drama as beleaguered Nurse Jessie Brewer. But the one time she was nominated for an award for her role on the soap, it was for a Golden Globe, not a Daytime Emmy.
Bryan Dattilo
Image Credit: Chris Haston/NBC/Courtesy of the Everett Collection
Approaching his 30th anniversary as Days of Our Lives’ Lucas Horton, the Salem mainstay has had it all. Frontburner storylines. Passionate fans. And an… oh. Nope, not once has Dattilo been celebrated with the Daytime Emmy nod that he’s earned.
Trevor St. John
Image Credit: John Paschal/JPI
He did the impossible and got One Life to Live fans to accept him as a replacement for future General Hospital star Roger Howarth (Austin) as Todd Manning — or so we thought at the time. But the only Emmy for which he was ever nominated was a fan award for Irresistible Combination with leading lady Kassie DePaiva (Blair).
Constance Ford
Image Credit: Courtesy of the Everett Collection
What on earth did the Daytime Emmys want? We have no idea, if over the course of this powerhouse’s 1967-92 run as tell-it-like-it-is Another World heroine Ada Hobson, she wasn’t able to move the decision-makers to freakin’ make her a nominee. Like, 10 times over!
Rick Springfield
Image Credit: ABC/Courtesy of the Everett Collection
The pop idol took General Hospital by storm in the 1980s. There was virtually no one that Noah Drake couldn’t seduce — except, that is, Academy voters, who refused to prescribe him an Emmy nomination for so charmingly “playing doctor.”
Lane Davies
Image Credit: NBC
The Santa Barbara leading man was less a silver-tongued devil than a gold-tongued one as acerbic heir apparent Mason Capwell. Yet not once for his superlative work was he even in the running for a Daytime Emmy. Shameful to the nth!
Kate Collins
Image Credit: ABC/Courtesy of the Everett Collection
We liked her. We really, really liked her. Nonetheless, the powerhouse who played both All My Children’s Natalie Marlowe and her twisted sister, “Janet From Another Planet,” didn’t once inspire her colleagues to put her in the mix for a Daytime Emmy.
Amber Tamblyn
Image Credit: ABC/Courtesy of the Everett Collection
Despite her star-making turn as the original Emily Quartermaine on General Hospital, the future movie star wouldn’t receive an Emmy nomination until 2004 — and that was for primetime’s Joan of Arcadia. #fail, Academy.
Kristina Wagner
Image Credit: ABC
Approaching her 40th anniversary on General Hospital, Felicia Scorpio’s portrayer has gotten to play everything: romances, action storylines, mysteries, even comedy. Despite her versatility, an Emmy nomination has frustratingly never come her way.
Louise Sorel
Image Credit: NBC/Courtesy of the Everett Collection
Whether playing the incorrigible Augusta Lockridge on Santa Barbara or the even more incorrigible Vivian Alamain on Days of Our Lives, this soap vet stood out… except, apparently, to her peers, who never gave her a single Emmy nod. Hmmph.
Joseph Mascolo
Image Credit: Dana Fineman/NBC/Courtesy of the Everett Collection
“Unthinkable” is the only word we can use to describe the fact that the late, great actor was never acknowledged with an Emmy nomination for either the mojo that he brought to bear as Massimo Marone on The Bold and the Beautiful or his iconic role of Stefano DiMera on Days of Our Lives.
Don Hastings
Image Credit: CBS/Courtesy of the Everett Collection
In 2004, the As the World Turns mainstay who played Dr. Bob Hughes for half a century, was presented with a Lifetime Achievement Award. But before that, nope, not once was he so much as nominated for a Daytime Emmy. How does that happen?!?