Credit: Stephane Cardinale/Corbis/Getty Images, Bruce Gilkas/FilmMagic/Getty Images, Tasia Wells/Getty Images
If Brooke is looking for a new love, she couldn’t do better than to pick one played by any of these familiar faces.
Richard Burgi
Image Credit: Howard Wise/JPI
When we first fell for him: As Chad Rollo on Another World. When we last fell for him: During his stint as Ashland Locke on Young & Restless. Now he could be: The outdoorsy landscaper who brings romance to full bloom as well as flowers.
Tuc Watkins
Image Credit: Jamie McCarthy/Getty Images
When we first fell for him: Every time he stole scenes as mischievous David Vickers on One Life to Live.When we last fell for him: As an Uncoupled heartbreaker. Now he could be: The budding restaurateur who puts romance on the menu for Brooke.
Peter Reckell
Image Credit: Paul Skipper/JPI (2)
When we first fell for him: When Bo Brady became Days of Our Lives‘ foremost protagonist. When we last fell for him: Same. Now he could be: The mechanic customizing a motorcycle for the birthday of Brooke’s son, R.J.
Michael Park
Image Credit: Monica Schipper/Getty Images
When we first fell for him: While he was playing Jack Snyder on As the World Turns. When we last fell for him: So far, that’s his one and only soap role. Now he could be: A construction foreman looking to build a future with Brooke.
John Schneider
Image Credit: Jim Steinfeldt/Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images
When we first fell for him: Way back when The Dukes of Hazzard was a hit. When we last fell for him: When he was stirring the pot as Jim Cryer on The Haves and the Have Nots.Now he could be: The gym owner who offers Brooke a different sort of workout.
Wes Ramsey
Image Credit: ABC
When we first fell for him: During his run as Sam Spencer on Guiding Light.When we last fell for him: As nefarious Peter August on General Hospital.Now he could be: The poolboy with whom Brooke can’t resist taking a dip.
Kamar de los Reyes
Image Credit: Vivien Killilea/Getty Images for Lighthouse Immersive/Impact Museums
When we first fell for him: During his stint as Antonio Vega on One Life to Live. When we last for him: Every time we’ve caught him in primetime. Now he could be: The public defender who takes Deacon’s case… and catches Brooke’s eye.
Jon Hensley
Image Credit: Howard Wise/JPI
When we first fell for him: The minute we saw him playing Holden Snyder on As the World Turns. When we last fell for him: When he guest-starred on Bold & Beautiful as Dr. Meade. Now he could be: That same character — easy peasy.
Lamman Rucker
Image Credit: Paras Griffin/Getty Images
When we first fell for him: As Marshall Travers on As the World Turns.When we last fell for him: As Jacob Greenleaf on primetime’s Greenleaf. Now he could be: The life coach who quickly becomes more of a love-life coach to Brooke.
William R. Moses
Image Credit: Paul Archuleta/FilmMagic/Getty Images
When we first fell for him: When he was Cole Gioberti on Falcon Crest. When we last fell for him: As Jeff Webber on General Hospital.Now he could be: An analyst friend of Taylor’s who wants to treat Brooke — but to dinner, not a therapy session!
A Martinez
Image Credit: Sean Smith/JPI
When we first fell for him: During his Emmy-winning run as Cruz Castillo on Santa Barbara.When we last fell for him: As Eduardo Hernandez on Days of Our Lives.Now he could be: A private eye that Brooke is keen on investigating extremely closely.
Ted King
Image Credit: Howard Wise/JPI
When we first fell for him: When he was playing Danny Roberts on Loving spinoff The City.When we last fell for him: Upon his introduction as Jack Finnegan on Bold & Beautiful.Now he could be: Just Jack, hello! He’d be catnip to Brooke.
Peter Parros
Image Credit: CBS/Courtesy of the Everett Collection, OWN
When we first fell for him: As Dr. Ben Price on One Life to Live.When we last fell for him: As “complicated” David Harrington on The Haves and the Have Nots.Now he could be: The Forrester security guard Charlie’s grooming to someday succeed him.
Robert Newman
Image Credit: Howard Wise/JPI
When we first fell for him: While he was playing Guiding Light hero Josh Lewis. When we last fell for him: During his stint as Young & Restless baddie Ashland Locke. Now he could be: The contractor tasked with remodeling Brooke’s office.
When we first fell for him: As Tom Gallagher on the short-lived Rituals. When we last fell for him: When he returned to Days of Our Lives as Craig Wesley. Now he could be: The shrink who counsels Brooke on her relationship patterns.
David A. Gregory
Image Credit: NBC
When we first fell for him: As he was playing hunkadaisical Robert Ford on One Life to Live.When we last fell for him: Did we ever fall out of love? Now he could be: The struggling artist trying to get hired as a Forrester photographer.
Ian Ziering
Image Credit: Ron Davis/Getty Images, Paul Archuleta/Getty Images
When we first fell for him: In his post-Guiding Light role of Steve Sanders on Beverly Hills, 902190.When we last fell for him: Can’t lie — we loved the Sharknado movies. Now he could be: The aspiring standup who never fails to leave Brooke laughing.
Eric Dane
Image Credit: Jon Kopaloff/FilmMagic/HBO/Getty Images
When we first fell for him: When he McSteamed up Grey’s Anatomy as Mark Sloan. When we last fell for him: During Mark’s appearance on Meredith’s “coma beach.” Now he could be: The personal trainer who encourages Brooke to run… but not from love.
Vincent Irizarry
Image Credit: Howard Wise/JPI
When we first fell for him: In his soap debut as Lujack Luvonaczek on Guiding Light.When we last fell for him: As Dr. Armstrong on Bold & Beautiful. Now he could be: That same character, back to give Brooke a particularly passionate “physical.”
John Wesley Shipp
Image Credit: Bobby Bank/WireImage/Getty Images
When we first fell for him: As Speedo-clad Guiding Light hunk Kelly Nelson. When we last fell for him: “Fell” might be the wrong word for how our reaction to One Life to Live‘s rotten Eddie Ford. Now he could be: The physical therapist who treats Brooke after an injury.