Sarah and Xander spy on Philip on Days of Our Lives

Jill Johnson/JPI

They were a little too happy too last.

They’ve been so, so happy. But now it seems Kristen’s plan to break up Sarah and Xander could be successful as Linsey Godfrey is out as Sarah Horton on Days of Our Lives. Leaving many a Xarah fan reeling.

In retrospect, the move shouldn’t come as too much of a surprise considering how utterly devoted and in love Sarah and Xander have been. Nothing has shaken them. Not Philip, not Rex, not Xander’s insecurity, not even everyone in Salem reminding Sarah of the many, many, terrible things Xander has done.

Though it all, Sarah has been unwavering in her devotion and Xander has been giddily shouting his love from the rooftops. Which, unfortunately, on soaps usually signals impending doom.

More: Photo gallery of recent Days exits

Much like Ben and Ciara, who got the big church wedding only to face months-long separation after walking down an exploding aisle as man and wife. Instead of a bomb though, it looks like Kristen will cause Xarah’s wedding to implode. Perhaps, her threat to send Sarah to that private island to languish offscreen will become a reality.

If that happens, Xander could pull a Ben and search heaven and earth to find his beloved. But, let’s be honest, we kinda see Xander spiraling and self-sabotaging in the wake of his heartbreak. Especially if he really thinks Sarah left him for good.

There are other options as well. Kristen could actually kill Sarah. Or, she could threaten Xander’s life, forcing Sarah to actually break up with him herself and leave town to protect him. Or, Rex could succeed in winning Sarah back, whereupon they walk off together into the sunset.

More: Is Godfrey returning to Bold & Beautiful? 

Just kidding. We can’t imagine a scenario where that last one would believably happen.

But whatever does play out, the good news is her absence isn’t necessarily permanent. Godfrey could return, just like several other Days of Our Lives actors who exited the show only to return months later, like Camila Banus (Gabi) and Galen Gering (Rafe). Then there’s Alison Sweeney, who has continued to pop up as Sami for years since “leaving” the NBC soap. Likewise, Victoria Konefal went off contract but is open to returning as Ciara when she can.

Until we learn Sarah’s fate, tell us what you hope happens in the wake of her exit. Then, remember Xarah’s good, bad, and downright silly times in the photo gallery below.

Then, get your free daily soap-opera fix for Days of Our Lives — and all of the other daytime dramas — delivered straight to your email inbox by signing up for Soaps.com’s newsletter.