Now that Nick has been shot, the list of suspects is long and everyone in Salem has a motive. Was it distraught Gabi, fearing for the control Nick was pressuring her with? Was it Sonny, protecting his husband and his rights as a father? Or could it have actually been the hit man EJ and Sami hired to take care of the job? The possibilities are endless, and Hope has a heck of a job ahead of her figuring out the true culprit.

Of course this is far from the first time a crime has been committed in town with a long list of suspects to weed through. From Stefano’s shooting in 2012 to figuring who was behind the Salem Strangler murders back in the early 1980s, mysteries have a long history on the show.

Vote in Soaps.com’s “Days” poll for what you consider to be the most memorable whodunit mystery in the show’s history, and let us know in the comments about any crimes we overlooked.