Madeline “Maddie” Coleman (PAST) (as played by Kelli Barrett on As the World Turns)
* 2005 - She was staging a fall at Katie's cottage, but Henry fell down the stairs instead, injuring his back.
* 2005 - Breaking and entering in the Lakeview Computer system.
* 2005 - Breaking and entering Mike Kasnoff's house.
* 2005 - Pretended to be Katie online.
* 2006 - Kept Will Munson and Gwen Norbeck hidden from the police.
* 2006 - Took Lia McDermott's sweater and set it on fire.
* 2006 - Vandalized Lia McDermott's car.
* 2006 - When Maddie was confronted by the police about the rape, she lied about the details.
* 2006 - When she was questioned about where she was when Lia McDermott was murdered, she lied to the police.
* 2006 - She was a suspect in the murders of Lia McDermott and Nate Bradley.
* 2006 - Threatened her brother in law, Louis Browning with a knife.
Kelli Barrett (December 22, 2008 - present)
Alexandra Chando (2005 - October 2007)
Maddie Coleman came to Oakdale right after Henry married Katie. Henry was surprised to see his baby sister show up in Oakdale, but he welcomed her. Shortly after arriving, she realized something wasn't quite right with Henry and Katie, and discovered that Henry was still living out of his limo. She knew Henry was very much in love with Katie and tried to help him hold onto her. However, Henry finally accepted the fact he and Katie would never be and moved on. Maddie moved in with Tom and Margo Hughes for a while. When she first arrived, Margo and Tom's son, Casey didn't like Maddie very much and they argued frequently. One day, they got caught up in the moment and shared a kiss. They couldn't get enough of each other.
One day, Maddie answered the door to see Dallas Griffin standing there. He was looking for his aunt Jessica and he thought she might be there. Before Maddie moved to Oakdale, she was raped by her brother-in-law. When she went to the hospital, she had to report the crime. She told the police officer that she sneaked out to a frat party and was raped there. The police officer was Dallas. Maddie had not told anyone about her rape, not even Henry. Now, she was worried that Dallas would tell. She immediately assumed the worst and even accused him of stalking her, but Dallas assured her it was just a coincidence that he was there too, and promised not to reveal her secret.
Maddie and Casey decided they were ready to move their relationship up a level. Margo and Tom were going to be out of town for the weekend and they decided to use that time to get closer. But when it was time, Maddie changed her mind and ran out on Casey. Seeing Dallas brought up the past. They broke up and Casey started dating Lia McDermott. Maddie sliced her tires one night out of anger. On a date with Casey, Lia was murdered. The police named Maddie as their top suspect. Maddie confessed to Margo that she was raped back in Chicago but it wasn't at a frat party, it was by her own brother-in-law, Louis Browning. When Louis came to Oakdale to see if he could get Maddie to come back home, her sister, Eve showed up in Oakdale to comfort her. Casey told his mom that he knew Maddie didn't kill Lia. Then another teenager was murdered. Maddie got the blame for it too. The police couldn't find enough evidence to name her the killer, but all of her friends said she was acting really strange. The teens decided to get away, before they had to start back to school. They went to Raven Lake. Once there, another teen was murdered. Shortly after, Maddie shows up looking confused. Everyone blamed Maddie and guarded her so she couldn't kill again. Over the next several hours, several more teens were murdered before it ended. When the slasher came after Maddie, she ran. Casey stepped in and brought the killer to the ground. Maddie removed the mask and was shocked to discover Eve! She was killing everyone hoping that Maddie would get the blame. Eve was jealous of Maddie and angry that Louis had fallen in love with her. She wanted Maddie to pay for it. Eve was put in prison.
Maddie was finally able to tell Casey everything. They shared a kiss and decided to give their relationship one more chance. Henry supported his sister every step of the way. Casey defended Maddie from the beginning, which made Maddie realize he was her true love. Casey loved Maddie enough to wait for the right moment to make love. He decided that he wasn't in such a hurry anymore.
Maddie became involved with newcomer Noah Mayer during the summer of 2007. Soon after becoming involved, Noah began having feelings for Luke Snyder. Trying to denying his feelings, Noah pressured Maddie to move in with him; she did and decided to attend Oakdale U rather that her dream college, Wesleyan. She eventually found out about Noah and Luke's attraction and broke things off with him. Not sure what to do next, Maddie finally decided she needed to be alone for a while and left town to attend Wesleyan.