List of Shows



    recommended for you


    Tell your friends

    TELL YOUR FRIENDS

    The Young and the Restless - MESSAGE BOARDS

    Soaps Boards :: The Young and the Restless Forum :: According to the latest SID and IMOW

    Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.

    According to the latest SID and IMOW

    Started by rediculous at 2013/05/20 02:21PM
    Latest post: 2013/05/22 07:54AM, Views: 3888, Replies: 30
    « 1 2 3 4 » »| page:
    #11   2013/05/20 03:31PM
    Re: According to the latest SID and IMOW
    Paggie
    image

    Quote RedTornado: This must be "Ridge", Ron Moss, from B&B.

    There is no way they are recasting Phyllis.

    Michelle Stafford is irreplaceable. It would be a travesty and slap in the face if JFP tried this stunt.



    Like it or not they have to recast Phyllis. There's the huge paternity story just breaking that impacts her character. She's been replaced before and at that time quite successfully by Sandra Nelson. It will be harder now because of the length of time she's been on the show and the way she has put her own stamp on the character. They said it couldn't be done with Jill - or Jack - but it was. So which FOJ is getting the call?

    #12   2013/05/20 05:58PM
    Re: According to the latest SID and IMOW
    go2girl
    image

    Quote rediculous:
    Quote go2girl: I don't want another Phyllis. I'd rather her character just be gone b/c no one can be Phyllis except MS. Furthermore, maybe her time with her sister and having a young child has made her realize she is missing too much in REAL life. Can't blame her for that. But I just can't see replacing her.


    Hey go2, we disagree on something, I think another actress could easily pick up this role, there are many talented people out there, no one owns a role IMO, anyone can be recast..I like MS as an actress also, but there can be another Phyllis..


    Probably so but I hated the replacement she had before even though that actress was good. Sometimes MS does do Phyllis over the top. But I loved her...

    #13   2013/05/20 06:10PM
    Re: According to the latest SID and IMOW
    LucySnowe
    image

    Quote rediculous:
    Quote go2girl: I don't want another Phyllis. I'd rather her character just be gone b/c no one can be Phyllis except MS. Furthermore, maybe her time with her sister and having a young child has made her realize she is missing too much in REAL life. Can't blame her for that. But I just can't see replacing her.


    Hey go2, we disagree on something, I think another actress could easily pick up this role, there are many talented people out there, no one owns a role IMO, anyone can be recast..I like MS as an actress also, but there can be another Phyllis..

    I think Robin Christopher would be good. What would be tough is having to make the switch in the midst of a big story.

    #14   2013/05/20 06:37PM
    Re: According to the latest SID and IMOW
    Grendel
    image

    Let Phyllis leave and go GA with Daniel and Lucy. I guess that will give Summer a lot more air time. We know she is one of the top young actors on the show. I think her role could get a lot bigger now.

    #15   2013/05/20 06:50PM
    Re: According to the latest SID and IMOW
    soapysuds75
    image

    Quote LucySnowe:
    Quote rediculous:
    Quote go2girl: I don't want another Phyllis. I'd rather her character just be gone b/c no one can be Phyllis except MS. Furthermore, maybe her time with her sister and having a young child has made her realize she is missing too much in REAL life. Can't blame her for that. But I just can't see replacing her.


    Hey go2, we disagree on something, I think another actress could easily pick up this role, there are many talented people out there, no one owns a role IMO, anyone can be recast..I like MS as an actress also, but there can be another Phyllis..

    I think Robin Christopher would be good. What would be tough is having to make the switch in the midst of a big story.


    This happens all the time. Peter Bergman took over for Terry Lester immediately. Michael Learned took over for Jeanne Cooper when she fell ill.

    More recently, Hunter Haley King took over the Summer role after Lindsay Bushman was fired by JFP. Hartley Sawyer took over for Blake Hood. Melissa Ordway took over for Marcy Emme Rylan.

    Soap fans understand it's the nature of show biz.

    #16   2013/05/20 06:54PM
    Re: According to the latest SID and IMOW
    sharon n nic...
    image

    I can't believe that she is leaving the show.

    I will miss MS.

    Phyllis not to much.

    #17   2013/05/21 01:07PM
    Re: According to the latest SID and IMOW
    masamf
    image

    Very few roles on Y&R are irreplaceable, IMO, there are only 3: Victor Newman, Drusilla Winters and Catherine Chancellor, the rest are all replaceable!! Those above 3 have proven to be the only 3 big shoes hard to fill. Phyllis has been recast before and the actress that took the role did the role good justice so......
    Wow, so MS is gone? Wow, just wow....I remember when I felt when it was announced that VR was leaving, guess no one lasts for ever on Y&R, so I'm not gonna gloat...I feel for MS fans though...it sucks out loud right now......to be MS or any of her fans I mean no one wants to lose a job in this recession!!!! Good luck to her, if the decision was hers.

    Modified 1 times(s), last time at: 2013/05/21 01:09PM
    #18   2013/05/21 01:12PM
    Re: According to the latest SID and IMOW
    Laloni
    image

    Quote rediculous:
    Quote go2girl: I don't want another Phyllis. I'd rather her character just be gone b/c no one can be Phyllis except MS. Furthermore, maybe her time with her sister and having a young child has made her realize she is missing too much in REAL life. Can't blame her for that. But I just can't see replacing her.


    Hey go2, we disagree on something, I think another actress could easily pick up this role, there are many talented people out there, no one owns a role IMO, anyone can be recast..I like MS as an actress also, but there can be another Phyllis..



    Nope, Phyllis will be hard to replace, they should just let her go and not replace her, if they need another woman on the show, fine, but don't call her Phyllis

    #19   2013/05/21 01:18PM
    Re: According to the latest SID and IMOW
    Radsbrat
    image

    Quote rediculous: an original cast member from one of the CBS soaps will be replaced. TPTB have big plans for this character and they are hoping to get an actor who can pull this off.....Fans will be shocked if this happens. Could this be the Phyllis character?


    My guess would Jeanne Cooper for obvious reasons.

    #20   2013/05/21 01:28PM
    Re: According to the latest SID and IMOW
    hotspice58
    image

    I read Jeanne Cooper wasn't going to be recast. it has to be Ronn Moss.

    « 1 2 3 4 » »| page:

    Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.

    « Go back to topic list