List of Shows



    Around the Web


    Tell your friends

    TELL YOUR FRIENDS

    The Young and the Restless - MESSAGE BOARDS

    Soaps Boards :: The Young and the Restless Forum :: Revenge or justice?

    Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.

    Revenge or justice?

    Started by mdtuttle at 2012/07/18 02:49PM
    Latest post: 2012/07/19 08:46AM, Views: 2505, Replies: 83
    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 » »| page:
    #1   2012/07/18 02:49PM
    Revenge or justice?
    mdtuttle
    image

    I can't help but wonder if Christine is chasing justice or revenge. Don't get me wrong, there is no doubt that Phyllis did commit the hit and run and I can understand Christine being angry. But after today's show I wonder which force is motivating her. Ronan asked her whether or not she though Phyllis had any emotional growth or changed in the years since the hit and run and Christine basically said she did not care.

    Ronan also pointed out that Chris circumvented the legal system to get a warrent and he is right. If it were anyone else the law would not go after Phyllis because of the staute of limitations. Since Christine apperently was on federal payroll at the time the limit does not pertain to crimes commited against her.

    Christine insisted on Phyllis being arested in fron of her family. She could have waited for them to leave but it almost seemed like she wanted to humilate Phyllis. She even insisted on cuffs but Ronan didn't comply.

    I think Phyllis should be held accountable for her actions but I fail to see what produtictive use jail would have at this point. Make her admit her crime, make her pay a huge fine, make her do some sort of major community service...Even go so far as to make her get counseling, although I do not think she has the anger management issues she once had. If it were anyone else but Phyllis I doubt Christine would be out for blood. She forgave Micheal for raping her but she can not conceed that Phyllis may have changed and has become a diffrent person as well. I think it is more about revenge than anything else.

    #2   2012/07/18 02:51PM
    Re: Revenge or justice?
    KeepingItReal
    image

    Well, I think its both but lawlfully it is "justice".

    Afterall Christine could be dead.

    Some should put themselves in the other person shoes and see how it feels....Michael, Lauren, etc... Have you ever been run down and left for dead....Lauren I think you can relate.

    #3   2012/07/18 02:54PM
    Re: Revenge or justice?
    Blue 501
    image

    Quote mdtuttle: I can't help but wonder if Christine is chasing justice or revenge. Don't get me wrong, there is no doubt that Phyllis did commit the hit and run and I can understand Christine being angry. But after today's show I wonder which force is motivating her. Ronan asked her whether or not she though Phyllis had any emotional growth or changed in the years since the hit and run and Christine basically said she did not care.

    Ronan also pointed out that Chris circumvented the legal system to get a warrent and he is right. If it were anyone else the law would not go after Phyllis because of the staute of limitations. Since Christine apperently was on federal payroll at the time the limit does not pertain to crimes commited against her.

    Christine insisted on Phyllis being arested in fron of her family. She could have waited for them to leave but it almost seemed like she wanted to humilate Phyllis. She even insisted on cuffs but Ronan didn't comply.

    I think Phyllis should be held accountable for her actions but I fail to see what produtictive use jail would have at this point. Make her admit her crime, make her pay a huge fine, make her do some sort of major community service...Even go so far as to make her get counseling, although I do not think she has the anger management issues she once had. If it were anyone else but Phyllis I doubt Christine would be out for blood. She forgave Micheal for raping her but she can not conceed that Phyllis may have changed and has become a diffrent person as well. I think it is more about revenge than anything else.


    Ronan had already given Phyllis a heads up that they were going to arrest her very soon. Why did SHE make a beeline for a public place? Did she think it would stay their hand?
    And I don't think Phyllis has changed. I think she would have killed Daisy if she thought she could get away with it.

    #4   2012/07/18 02:55PM
    Re: Revenge or justice?
    Blue 501
    image

    And quite frankly, I think Christine is entitled to both justice and "revenge" if you want to call prosecuting a criminal that.

    #5   2012/07/18 02:57PM
    Re: Revenge or justice?
    lisa diane
    image

    Great Post, I don't know maybe its a little of both, I mean I would want justice that is for sure no matter how long ago it was so I can see her point on that one. I didn't watch today yet but I think she may want her embarrassed in front of her friends and family , right now all she wants is Phylis to pay. If this was Phylis she would be doing the same exact thing. Look how many times she wrote in her magazine about people, remember while back when she lurked around everyone , just about all the female characters and wrote about them in the magazine that was embarrassing for them not only for their rep but for their kids to see. Phylis had no remorse about that, she didn't care if their loved ones seen it and none of these people hit her and run after, so there was no reason for her to do this to these people. Christine was H and R by this lady so she wants her to pay with both revenge and justice and in my opinion Phylis deserves it. If Phylis can do this to others for no reason, or just to get a story in a magazine no matter who she hurts then I say Christine has the right to do this.

    #6   2012/07/18 02:57PM
    Re: Revenge or justice?
    jtb1974
    image

    Does it really make a difference? Both are warranted. Revenge and justice go hand in hand.

    #7   2012/07/18 02:59PM
    Re: Revenge or justice?
    Lucy3
    image

    Quote Blue 501:
    Quote mdtuttle: I can't help but wonder if Christine is chasing justice or revenge. Don't get me wrong, there is no doubt that Phyllis did commit the hit and run and I can understand Christine being angry. But after today's show I wonder which force is motivating her. Ronan asked her whether or not she though Phyllis had any emotional growth or changed in the years since the hit and run and Christine basically said she did not care.

    Ronan also pointed out that Chris circumvented the legal system to get a warrent and he is right. If it were anyone else the law would not go after Phyllis because of the staute of limitations. Since Christine apperently was on federal payroll at the time the limit does not pertain to crimes commited against her.

    Christine insisted on Phyllis being arested in fron of her family. She could have waited for them to leave but it almost seemed like she wanted to humilate Phyllis. She even insisted on cuffs but Ronan didn't comply.

    I think Phyllis should be held accountable for her actions but I fail to see what produtictive use jail would have at this point. Make her admit her crime, make her pay a huge fine, make her do some sort of major community service...Even go so far as to make her get counseling, although I do not think she has the anger management issues she once had. If it were anyone else but Phyllis I doubt Christine would be out for blood. She forgave Micheal for raping her but she can not conceed that Phyllis may have changed and has become a diffrent person as well. I think it is more about revenge than anything else.


    Ronan had already given Phyllis a heads up that they were going to arrest her very soon. Why did SHE make a beeline for a public place? Did she think it would stay their hand?
    And I don't think Phyllis has changed. I think she would have killed Daisy if she thought she could get away with it.
    And didn't Chris mention going to the penthouse and Ronan said Phyllis wasn't there? Why didn't he call her and tell her to come to the station?

    As for the original question, in my opinion it's probably a bit of both. And who can blame her? I know I'd want both and I'll bet many others would too.

    #8   2012/07/18 03:01PM
    Re: Revenge or justice?
    Pinchy
    image

    Quote mdtuttle: I can't help but wonder if Christine is chasing justice or revenge. Don't get me wrong, there is no doubt that Phyllis did commit the hit and run and I can understand Christine being angry. But after today's show I wonder which force is motivating her. Ronan asked her whether or not she though Phyllis had any emotional growth or changed in the years since the hit and run and Christine basically said she did not care.

    Ronan also pointed out that Chris circumvented the legal system to get a warrent and he is right. If it were anyone else the law would not go after Phyllis because of the staute of limitations. Since Christine apperently was on federal payroll at the time the limit does not pertain to crimes commited against her.

    Christine insisted on Phyllis being arested in fron of her family. She could have waited for them to leave but it almost seemed like she wanted to humilate Phyllis. She even insisted on cuffs but Ronan didn't comply.

    I think Phyllis should be held accountable for her actions but I fail to see what produtictive use jail would have at this point. Make her admit her crime, make her pay a huge fine, make her do some sort of major community service...Even go so far as to make her get counseling, although I do not think she has the anger management issues she once had. If it were anyone else but Phyllis I doubt Christine would be out for blood. She forgave Micheal for raping her but she can not conceed that Phyllis may have changed and has become a diffrent person as well. I think it is more about revenge than anything else.


    But Phyllis may not receive jail time whatsoever. This is just Christines wish and honestly I don't blame her.

    If I just found out who tried to run me over years ago, I sure wouldn't be hopping on the forgiveness bandwagon right away. Nope I would be looking for blood.

    Phyllis might just end up with community service but to not prosecute her is not justice either. She should be held accountable for her crimes whether she's a changed individual today or not.

    Honestly, if she had any kind of integrity she would admit her mistake and try to make amends. Then maybe I would hop on the forgiveness bandwagon but not beforehand!

    #9   2012/07/18 03:05PM
    Re: Revenge or justice?
    lisa diane
    image

    That is with me also, I would give her a break if she would just be honest and show remorse to what she has done, I still don't see remorse, all that I see is the hatred she has in Christine like it is her fault she is in trouble. Phylis holds everyone else for her problems and her evil ways, it is always some one else fault. You know when a kid says " well they made me do it" well that is how Phylis thinks. They made me do it. Phylis hasn't changed one bit since that incident 20 years ago, every time she does something evil to someone she never has remorse. Evil comes natural to her.

    #10   2012/07/18 03:06PM
    Re: Revenge or justice?
    mdtuttle
    image

    Quote KeepingItReal: Well, I think its both but lawlfully it is "justice".

    Afterall Christine could be dead.

    Some should put themselves in the other person shoes and see how it feels....Michael, Lauren, etc... Have you ever been run down and left for dead....Lauren I think you can relate.


    I do agree that Christine has every right to be upset and want some kind of justice for what Phyllis did to her. But I also think we need to measure how Christine has forgiven other poeple that have wronged her in the past.

    Micheal raped her and for this he was disbarred and jailed. Christine forgave him when he said he was a changed man. Helped him get out of jail and even helped him get his license to practice law back. For a while she was even a partner in his law firm and look at Micheal now he is a well respected member of the community.

    Danny cheated on Christine when they were married but she forgave him and put all the blame on Phylliss.

    Nina and Christine have had issues but she has always been forgiving of Nina.

    Pauk and Christine's marriage ended but she holds no ill will against him

    I wil grant that with the possible exception of Micheal's crime against Christine all these other examples pail in comparision to what Phyllis did. But my point is Phyllis could be forced to face and admit her crime and even pay for what she did without being sent to prison. At this point I do not see Jail as serving any constructive purpose.

    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 » »| page:

    Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.

    « Go back to topic list