Still at Rodi's Cole is on the phone with St. Ann's. They won't put him through to Hannah. She's with her lawyer. The nun does admit to Cole that she finds it hard to believe that the Hannah she's gotten to know would've done the things she's accused of.
Eli holds a gun on Hannah in her room at St. Ann's. Hannah begs Eli to spare her. "Of course I'm not going to kill you," Eli says. "You're going to kill yourself." Eli pulls out a bottle of pills. After everything Hannah's admitted to doing no one will think it's odd that she committed suicide. "Forget it," Hannah snaps, knocking the pills from Eli's hand. "If you want me dead you're going to have to do it!" Eli threatens to kill Cole and throw him in the Llantano River. Eli dumps the bottle of pills in Hannah's hand and orders her to swallow them. She does and cries, "Cole…"
At the station John receives a call from Glenn's office relaying that Glenn's dead! The man claims Glenn was found collapsed holding a fax with John's name on it. John hangs up and relays the news to Kelly who thinks Glenn died of a heartache after seeing Eli aka Bennett's photo. Kelly wants Eli arrested but John needs proof. Kelly wants to break into Eli's room. John warns her to stay out of this and let him do his job! Kelly promises not to do anything stupid and leaves.
Jack rushes into the mansion living room screaming that Blair can't marry Eli because he's a killer! He starts ranting about the movie he watched and asks where Dorian keeps her gun. Blair blames Todd for allowing Jack to watch such films. She promises Jack Eli is a good guy. Blair continues to pack until John calls looking for Eli. "Don't tell me you think he's a psycho killer too?" Blair asks into the phone. "Is that McPain?" Jack asks. "Let me talk to him!" Blair ignores Jack and assures John she'll tell Eli to call him. Jack starts unpacking Blair's suitcase. Blair begs him to be happy for her and throws the clothes back in. She's sick of Jack acting out and grounds him. Jack refuses to go to his room because he has to get back to his dad's. Todd's marrying Tea! Blair didn't know but thinks Jack's outburst is due to him wanting her and Todd back together. Blair urges him to accept that Todd's going to marry Tea and she's going to marry Eli. "Fine! It's going to be your funeral, not mine," Jack says before storming off. Kelly arrives, hears Blair's eloping and orders, "You can't marry Eli!"
Cole arrives home to find Starr upset. Starr explains that Tea's dying. She says like Tea's other two marriages to Todd this one will be over before it even begins.
Over at Todd's Tea assures Dani she wouldn't want anyone else standing by her side when she marries Todd. Tea and Dani head upstairs to get ready. Todd listens from outside the bedroom door as Tea tells Dani about her and Todd's first marriage. "You married Todd for money?" Dani gasps. "Yeah but he married me for his daughter," Tea replies. Tea has no regrets and talks of their second wedding, which was like a fairytale. She loves Todd and he gave her Dani. Tea apologizes for lying to her about Todd and asks Dani not to make the same mistakes she did. Todd smiles from the doorway. Later, Tea runs into Todd in the hallway. She playfully scolds him for eavesdropping. He kisses her, saying they still have time to get this marriage right. Tea goes off alone and stares at a photo of Todd when he had his old face.
Dani joins Todd downstairs and offers to help him get ready. Starr arrives. Todd's so happy to have his girls with him. Starr leans her head on Todd's shoulder while Dani takes his hand. Dani looks through photos of Todd and Tea's past marriages and asks Todd, "Do you ever miss your old face?" Tea appears and shocks everyone by saying to Todd, "There's no way in hell I'm marrying you. You are not Todd Manning!"
Gigi pulls up to the Llanview Family Clinic. She wonders if Natalie is sure about her decision. "I have to get an abortion," Natalie replies. Gigi brings up John but Natalie can't forget that the baby could be Brody's. Natalie thinks about how things could turn out for everyone if that happens. Gigi warns Natalie if she has the abortion she needs to be able to live with the decision. Natalie thinks about what this could do to Jessica and Brody - and to her and her sister. "I know I'll lose my sister over this," Natalie says. "Then I'll lose John." Just then John calls. He wants to see her and says, "Where are you at? I'll come meet you." Natalie asks for a raincheck. She's in the middle of something. Natalie agrees to call John when she's done then hangs up. Gigi gives Natalie the time. "It's time for my appointment," Natalie says.
Next on One Life to Live:
Kelly warns Blair that she suspects Eli is a murderer.