At Kyle's, Fish admits he always felt the connection to Sierra, which became more paternal since she was kidnapped.
Over at Rex's loft, after Roxy explains how she got free from Allison, she breaks down and says, "Allison told me something about you and me, Rexy." Crying, Roxy says, "Mitch is not your father." She admits Mitch got her pregnant, Allison spent nine months checking up on her and she drank during her pregnancy to forget Mitch was the father. Rex and Natalie try to comfort her, as Roxy professes her love for them both, saying, "You'll always be my kids." Roxy remembers her baby being sick, and hoping her baby would die so she'd have no further connection to Mitch, but then Allison returned with her baby. Roxy didn't recognize the baby but allowed Allison to convince her he was hers. "Somebody left you at the hospital," Roxy tells Rex then continues, "Mitch isn't your father, and I'm not your mother." Roxy breaks down in Natalie's arms, as Rex's world as he's known it comes crashing down around him. "Who am I?" Rex asks, and Roxy goes to him and holds him close.
At Statesville, Bo rants at the warden for allowing Allison to take the baby in the infirmary. Brody arrives, and the warden wonders if his Navy Seal experience will help with this hostage situation. While going over the prison blueprints, just as Bo informs Brody and the warden that they are going in, Fish arrives and asks to be the one to save Sierra because he's her father!
Inside the infirmary, Allison, holding Sierra's carseat, aims a gun on Schuyler warning he better administer the antidote or else. Schuyler begs Allison to give Sierra to him before it's too late for Mitch. As Mitch grabs his heart and tells Allison to hand over the baby, Allison goes on to tell Mitch that Sierra is indeed his granddaughter because he's Schuyler's father! Schuyler and Mitch don't believe it and are shocked when Allison recalls how her sister, Dr. Joplin, worked at a hospital and Mitch's son's heart was failing. "But fate stepped in and solved the problem," Allison says then remembers how a healthy baby was left by its mother, one Allison claimed as her own. "They believed me," she says, but Schuyler wonders how he's Mitch's son if Mitch's son died? Allison goes on to tell Schuyler that Mitch's baby didn't die, her sister saved him, and Roxy had already left with the healthy baby. Allison claimed to Dr. Joplin that she gave birth to the baby, but when Allison refused to raise him, Dr. Joplin reluctantly did, as her own. "That's how Leah Joplin became the biological mother of your child, Mitch," Allison admits. Schuyler and Mitch make eye contact, as Allison introduces them as father and son.
Marty is rushed into the hospital, with John forced to wait in the hall while the doctor examines Marty. John looks at the missed call from Natalie then gets a call from Bo, who fills him in on the recent turn of events. Bo says he has everything under control and urges John to stay with Marty.
John is called into the exam room, and though the baby is okay, the doctor explains that Marty's blood pressure is high and is a serious problem. "This is a high risk pregnancy," the doctor warns then gives Marty instructions on how to take care of herself. John assures the doctor, as does Marty, that she'll do everything needed to protect the baby. Once alone, John puts his hand on Marty's belly, says he loves their baby then insists that she move in with him.
In the gym, Cris and Jessica playfully get paint on each other until Layla appears, irked. After Cris takes a call from Brody, saying they found Allison, so Cris is off Jessica duty, Cris tells Jessica they're done for the day. Jessica leaves to clean up, and Cris explains that he allowed Jessica to help with the musical sets as a favor to Brody but that more kids should be signing up soon. As Layla accepts Cris' explanation, and kiss, Jessica watches, upset. However, before she leaves, she tells Cris she'll see him tomorrow then says goodbye to Layla. On her way out, Jessica rips down the notice asking for more help with the sets!
Clint and Kim enter the Buchanan Mansion living room. After a brief talk about Allison having been found, Kim wonders if Clint is sure he's ready to raise another kid. Clint is and gives Kim a parenting book and a diamond necklace to go with it. Just as Clint and Kim head upstairs to have some fun, Jessica calls and asks for a ride home from school. After Clint leaves, Kim answers the door, sees David then says, "What do you want?"
Clint arrives at the high school, and Jessica gives her father a happy hug hello.
Next on One Life to Live:
Rex is devastated.
Schuyler gets the upper hand on Mitch and Allison.