Due to a press conference with remarks made by President Obama, the first five minutes of One Life to Live were not shown. The show resumed and recap began at 2:05 pm.
Bo and Nora discuss Matthew's attacker at home. A furious Nora asks Bo why he didn't arrest Nate. He doesn't think that Nate knew what would happen to Matthew when he hit him and has been in his own private hell. Nora retorts that Matthew is also in hell and doesn't think his attacker should go free. Bo reminds her of what Matthew did to Eddie, and if they pursue prosecuting Nate, everything will come out. "We can't go after Nate without giving up Matthew," he tells Nora. She doesn't want him tucked away in some prison hospital. Bo believes if they had let Matthew originally confess, then Nate wouldn't have found out the way he did. He blames himself and Nora for Matthew's condition. Nora has a meltdown over all the things Matthew will never experience. Bo embraces her and promises to help her move forward. Nora abruptly turns the subject to dinner and offers to go get takeout so she can get some fresh air.
Vivian and Shaun discuss Destiny's options at the hospital. Destiny explains that she and Matthew were not a couple when they hooked up. She wants to do everything that young adults should experience and isn't ready to be a parent. She admits she wants an abortion. Vivian explains that she has a 24-hour waiting period, and leaves to schedule the procedure. Alone with Shaun, Destiny cries for causing trouble by not using protection, but is not sorry for making love to Matthew. Shaun believes she might need to talk to her mother, but Destiny asserts she has no mother. He believes that his parents were doing the best they could, but Destiny doesn't want them to know. Vivian returns and says, "I'm sorry, but that's a promise he can't keep." She reveals that Destiny has to get parental consent to have the abortion.
Destiny goes to see her mother. Her mom is overjoyed to see her, but Destiny disappoints her with the news that she is not staying. She is shocked when Destiny hands her an abortion consent form to sign.
Nate goes to see Dani and tell her about his chat with Bo. He reveals that he confessed everything, and she is worried about what will happen next. He doesn't know, but is happy she agreed to protect him after everything has happened. Nate laments not knowing if he'll be arrested. He takes Dani's hands, but she pulls away. She changes the subject and doesn't think Nora and Bo will prosecute him because they want to protect Matthew. He wishes his mistakes he made with his father didn't cost him her. Dani thinks she is at fault, too. Nate believes they could start over and begs for a second chance. He pledges his love to her, but she can't give him an answer right now. She doesn't know if she can block out the images of his porno, but promises the decision will be hers and not influenced by Todd.
Nate returns home and looks at pictures of happier times with Dani. He is surprised when Nora arrives at his door. An angry Nora tells him, "I want to talk to you about what happened with Matthew."
At Todd's house, both Todd and T.M. both claim to have raped Marty. T.M. is shocked when he learns that Todd had a relationship with Marty. An incredulous T.M. thinks that should have been a clue that Todd was an imposter. John then reveals that the DNA sample that matched Marty's rape kit belongs to T.M. Todd claims the test proves nothing. Viki asks who he really is, but he screams, "What happened to innocent until proven guilty?" Todd is disgusted no one believes him, but Jack pipes up that he believes him. Blair yells at Todd to stop playing games. John announces they will know who Todd is when they open his DNA results. Todd brings up the illegal procedure used to obtain his toothbrush, but John believes it is irrelevant at this point. Todd wants a new test, but John opens the envelope. John causes further confusion when the results show Todd's DNA is also a match. The group is stunned when John says, "According to this test, you are Todd Manning, too."