Time to stop Phyllis bashing

Y&R lovers! Here's your chance to rant and rave about everything in Genoa City!
User avatar
Sunnyflower
Posts: 34556
Joined: Mon Jul 09, 2007 9:27 am

Re: Time to stop Phyllis bashing

Postby Sunnyflower » Thu Nov 22, 2007 1:16 pm

Quote Soulsistah: Yes, I really wish they did consult with legal personnel so the court-room/trial s/ls aren't so lame.

I agree, Phyllis getting 6 years for this white-collar crime was stretching it more than a bit just for the sake of a Phyllis s/l. But I'll take what I can get given she hasn't done a day of jail time for much more serious (and deadly) crimes she's committed in the past, for which if they were being depictedly realistically, she'd have been sentenced to a much longer term than a paltry 6 years. ~) She deserved to be locked up for life!


See that is just it. Phyllis needed her day in court, if you will, for the awful things she did in the past, and so they came up with this, which is completely lame.

The writers are just so lazy, IMO.

User avatar
Soulsistah
Posts: 15895
Joined: Thu Feb 01, 2007 2:11 pm

Re: Time to stop Phyllis bashing

Postby Soulsistah » Thu Nov 22, 2007 2:23 pm

Quote Sunnyflower:
Quote Soulsistah: Yes, I really wish they did consult with legal personnel so the court-room/trial s/ls aren't so lame.

I agree, Phyllis getting 6 years for this white-collar crime was stretching it more than a bit just for the sake of a Phyllis s/l. But I'll take what I can get given she hasn't done a day of jail time for much more serious (and deadly) crimes she's committed in the past, for which if they were being depictedly realistically, she'd have been sentenced to a much longer term than a paltry 6 years. ~) She deserved to be locked up for life!


See that is just it. Phyllis needed her day in court, if you will, for the awful things she did in the past, and so they came up with this, which is completely lame.

The writers are just so lazy, IMO.


ITA. And as KIR said, we do need the criminals free to continue to wreak havoc or the s/ls would be even more boring! :)

User avatar
Candace
Posts: 12697
Joined: Mon Dec 04, 2006 9:11 am

Re: Time to stop Phyllis bashing

Postby Candace » Thu Nov 22, 2007 2:43 pm

Shelia is evil and twisted. IMO, Phyllis is nothing like that. Seems most of the characters are just one crisis away from going psycho or maiming someone or cheating with someone...That's the great thing about soaps!

KeepingItReal
Posts: 32663
Joined: Tue Aug 29, 2006 2:07 pm

Re: Time to stop Phyllis bashing

Postby KeepingItReal » Thu Nov 22, 2007 2:45 pm

Quote Candace: Shelia is evil and twisted. IMO, Phyllis is nothing like that. Seems most of the characters are just one crisis away from going psycho or maiming someone or cheating with someone...That's the great thing about soaps!


I agree she is not but I do believe she is boarder line......just one more thing and she too will snap.

Sheilla's was the lost of her child and not being able to keep a man.

User avatar
cater2u
Posts: 1013
Joined: Thu Jul 19, 2007 6:37 pm

Re: Time to stop Phyllis bashing

Postby cater2u » Thu Nov 22, 2007 2:48 pm

Quote Wickyz: Ok ya'll time to stop bashing Phyllis for blackmailing Brad...and making Sharon out to be the victim in it...I just did my Y&R homework and back a few years ago..Sharon did the same thing to Nikki concerning Abbys paternity so I say....what comes around goes around Sharon...and it always comes back to bite ya 10 fold!!!


ohh yes that did happen din't it..wow that's ben awhile back..sharon are phllis are so alike ..i don't know why so many ppl chose to disregard it..and im not pointing directly to any one on this board :D

User avatar
Wickyz
Posts: 240
Joined: Fri Oct 19, 2007 1:03 pm

Re: Time to stop Phyllis bashing

Postby Wickyz » Thu Nov 22, 2007 3:09 pm

Quote suegerry: Gee what a thread.....

l. when did Sharon become a murderer and attempt murderer

2. when did she blackmail Nikki

3. when did Phyllis redeemed herself

4. I don't believe she will ever change

5. Lame Nick is not in love with her and she knows that

6. her daughter Summe's is Jack's little girl

7. she conceived this child while she was having
pitty sex with Jack :-)

8. its just a mather of time before they reunite
Shick then this show can go back to be what it
used to be

9. Nick has primative amnesia, the reason why he
was talking to Vikki about last years Thanksgiving
I think sometime he forgets he's faking this amnesia

Gee .....how's this for bashing....and having fun :-)



Lets see...did you forget about Cameron? Didnt Sharon believe she killed him and tried to hide the body...hmmmm Sharon sure did Blackmail Nikki...when she overheard Nikki talking about Abbys paternity...Told Nikki if she didnt let her have the gala and behave AT IT..she was going with Victor with the truth about Abbys paternity..maybe she didnt gain monetarily but she did gain something out of it....Maybe SOMEONE needs to go back and review their Y&R history!!!!

User avatar
Wickyz
Posts: 240
Joined: Fri Oct 19, 2007 1:03 pm

Re: Time to stop Phyllis bashing

Postby Wickyz » Thu Nov 22, 2007 3:14 pm

Quote cater2u:
Quote Wickyz: Ok ya'll time to stop bashing Phyllis for blackmailing Brad...and making Sharon out to be the victim in it...I just did my Y&R homework and back a few years ago..Sharon did the same thing to Nikki concerning Abbys paternity so I say....what comes around goes around Sharon...and it always comes back to bite ya 10 fold!!!


ohh yes that did happen din't it..wow that's ben awhile back..sharon are phllis are so alike ..i don't know why so many ppl chose to disregard it..and im not pointing directly to any one on this board :D


I think alot of people tend to disregard alot of the past...Sharon had MULTIPLE affairs while married to Nick Cameron, Diego, Brad...She has lied, schemed and screwed people over to get what she wants....Sharon isnt any better then anyone else!!!

KeepingItReal
Posts: 32663
Joined: Tue Aug 29, 2006 2:07 pm

Re: Time to stop Phyllis bashing

Postby KeepingItReal » Thu Nov 22, 2007 3:19 pm

Trust me I was not a "fan" of Sharon in the past and could not stand the wishy washiness of her character.

But when you compare her "afairs" and last time I checked it was not a punishable crime and compare them to Phyllis who we allllllllll know commited those crimes there is a "difference". ;)

I just prefer to side with someone that's not a criminal and who honestly "regrets" her infidelity. ;)

Phyllis on the other hand does not regret anything much less have a conscience otherwise when she got out of jail she would of just walked past Brad and not made her remark and have kept her mouth shut and not said what she said to Nikki- very tacky and insensitive. ;)

User avatar
cater2u
Posts: 1013
Joined: Thu Jul 19, 2007 6:37 pm

Re: Time to stop Phyllis bashing

Postby cater2u » Thu Nov 22, 2007 3:20 pm

Quote Wickyz:
Quote cater2u:
Quote Wickyz: Ok ya'll time to stop bashing Phyllis for blackmailing Brad...and making Sharon out to be the victim in it...I just did my Y&R homework and back a few years ago..Sharon did the same thing to Nikki concerning Abbys paternity so I say....what comes around goes around Sharon...and it always comes back to bite ya 10 fold!!!


ohh yes that did happen din't it..wow that's ben awhile back..sharon are phllis are so alike ..i don't know why so many ppl chose to disregard it..and im not pointing directly to any one on this board :D


I think alot of people tend to disregard alot of the past...Sharon had MULTIPLE affairs while married to Nick Cameron, Diego, Brad...She has lied, schemed and screwed people over to get what she wants....Sharon isnt any better then anyone else!!!


ITA with that sharon ain't that wonderful but her fans will see it the other way just like phyllis fans will often disregard any bad things she done..each fan base likes to call out on what the other has done. it's a vicious cycle and it doesn't end. some are just more upfront abot it than others ~) . you see whenever there is a discusion based on phyllis there is always talk about her her past...and about the future many still attempt to predict that she'll stil being done stupid things down the line. I personally like to live in the prsent so i'll keep the talk of the the past to a minmum and the talk of the future i dare not go in that direction because it's foolish IMO

KeepingItReal
Posts: 32663
Joined: Tue Aug 29, 2006 2:07 pm

Re: Time to stop Phyllis bashing

Postby KeepingItReal » Thu Nov 22, 2007 3:27 pm

I never like Phyllis also when she came to GC. Dang girl was always plotting and scheminng.

Like I said when they pair her with Jack she was a better person.

But hey, we need a villian and since that's how she started out and continue to progress "so be it". Let it be let it be let be :-)


Return to “The Young and the Restless”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: sparklepony and 2 guests

Back to Top