Silas suddenly appears at PCPD and grabs West roughly, upset about his visit to Sam. Dante pulls Silas off West and Silas agrees to answer West’s questions. They head into the interrogation room and West asks if Nina was on antidepressants because of his affair with Ava, because at the time Silas denied his affair. Silas didn’t think it was relevant to her overdose. West slides over a bag with a prescription for Nina’s antidepressant in its liquid form, prescribed to Silas the day his wife went into her coma. West think Silas wrote it, filled it and injected Nina. Silas says he never saw it and leaves. Outside, Michael arrives and asks Dante for help finding Carly. Michael doesn’t trust Franco and begs Dante for help. They leave together.
Alexis visits Sam at the penthouse. She heard from Molly that Sam and Silas had a nice New Year’s Eve and she’s happy someone appreciates Sam for the amazing woman she is. She asks if things are getting serious and Sam tells her they were – until she found out Silas had a wife. Sam tells her everything and Alexis wonders why he kept it a secret until now. Sam admits she found out the truth from a cop. When she asked Silas, he told her the whole story. When Silas' wife went into a coma, the cops suspected Silas because of his affair with Ava. Alexis is surprised how much Silas has kept hidden but has to dash when she gets a text. Later, Sam lets Silas in and he tells her about West’s prescription evidence. They both wonder if Ava is to blame.
At Sabrina’s, Carlos promises her that he will make her happy and be there for her and the baby. Patrick knocks and Sabrina pushes Carlos to hide. Whatever she says to Patrick, he isn’t a part of it. She opens the door and Patrick asks if she’s pregnant. She admits she is while Carlos listens from the bedroom. Patrick is surprised considering how safe they were, but offers to support her no matter what. Carlos enters and tells Patrick not to worry – the baby is his. Patrick doesn’t believe him, but Carlos tells him they slept together after the called-off wedding. Patrick looks to Sabrina for confirmation.
Kiki asks Ava outside Franco’s hotel room what happened to Carly. Kiki heard Ava threaten Carly at the restaurant. Ava swears she didn’t do anything to Carly but Kiki doesn’t believe a word she says. Ava is sorry and walks off. Inside, Franco finds Carly’s letter. She writes that Sonny made her see she was putting her relationship with him over her son. She didn’t want to end things this way, but she thinks it is best for everyone if she went out of town for a few days. Kiki returns and he shows her the note. He is upset – they were really good together. Franco can’t think what happened to change Carly’s mind. Kiki leaves a message for Michael, then comforts Franco. He demands to know why Kiki is being nice to him and she tells him that even though they are not related she still cares about him. She offers to help him find Carly.
Heather removes Carly’s gag and offers her the time to say her last words in the boathouse. Carly tells Heather she can’t kill her because they are two of a kind. They are both mothers to two boys. Heather agrees, but her sons don’t appreciate her. Franco is the worst. He stabbed her with her own knife, which is why she has to do this. Heather later leaves the boathouse with a bloody knife. She tells herself Carly deserved it and so did Franco.
Morgan slams Julian against the Metro Court parking garage wall, demanding to know what happened to Carly. Morgan has done everything Julian has asked, including humiliating Ava in front of his father. Julian denies any involvement and is upset to learn Ava went to Paluzzo’s. Michael and Dante walk up and ask Morgan what he’s doing with Julian. They play it off like they just ran into each other and Julian leaves. Meanwhile, Heather parks Carly’s car and pats herself on the back for a job well done. Morgan, Michael and Dante make a plan, then see Carly’s car. Heather is gone, the door is open and there is blood smeared on the side. They pop the trunk.
Julian finds Ava at her hotel room and questions her about Carly. Did she make her disappear? Later, West calls Ava and asks her to come to the station.
Tomorrow’s Port Charles spoilers for General Hospital:
Sam wonders if Ava tried to kill Nina.
Ava tells Det. West she doesn’t know a thing about Carly.
Olivia asks Sonny if he thinks Morgan is really done with Ava.