Outside the Haunted Star, Luke worries some psycho from his past with Laura is trying to haunt them. Scott Baldwin emerges and tells Luke he’s in town for Laura – his fiancée. Laura confirms it and Luke is floored. When Luke asks Laura why, Scott replies he is just putting things back the way they were before Luke screwed them up. Luke asks Laura directly if she loves Scott. She does, and wants to marry him.
Alexis goes to the penthouse but Sam doesn’t answer. Shawn offers to break down the door, but she lets herself in with her key. The place is empty and she worries someone took Sam. Alexis doesn’t think John committed those murders and worries Heather took them both. But what if John did snap?
Anna walks by the pier and is surprised by Duke. She apologizes for being poor company, but she is trying to figure something outrageous out - whether there could be two John McBains. Duke read about the stabbings and they discuss how difficult it is to believe John could do it. Duke thinks it is possible that there are two Johns considering what Faison did to him. Anna is scared to use her gut because of how she reacted to Faison’s trap. Duke reveals he is still in love with her and will wait as long as it takes for her to make her choice. She reveals she ended it with Luke. He is not the love of her life, and she isn’t his. They are about to kiss when Alexis calls Anna to tell her Sam is missing. They agree to meet at the station and Duke encourages Anna to trust her gut.
Kate wakes up in bed with Sonny, confused. She wonders why they are on Johnny’s boat, and he tells her about the party and that it is not Johnny's boat anymore. She has been gone for five months. They didn’t get married because she married Johnny, but it’s okay. She suddenly wonders why they are in bed together. Did he sleep with Connie? He admits he did and she’s disgusted with Sonny. He tries to tell her things are different now but she refuses to hear his explanations and storms out.
At home, Olivia hears a crash, then sees Steve emerge from the bathroom with a massive stomach wound. She tries to call 911, but he is fine. The mirror broke and he was just coming out to get a dustpan. She tells him about her bloody vision and is worried about the person stabbing people. She doesn’t believe it’s John and thinks it could be Heather. She won’t believe otherwise until she sees a corpse. He assures her he is not going anywhere and they start making out. There is a knock at the door and Olivia is shocked to hear it is Kate.
Todd and Rafe share a cell at PCPD, and John is one cell over. Todd thinks he and Rafe can help each other since they both saw John commit murder. Todd questions John if he is going to change his story now but John refuses. He didn’t do those things – Caleb did. What would John have to gain by killing Heather and stealing Danny? And what about Todd’s own case of double identity? He has been where John is, trying to convince people of something outrageous but true. Todd tells John he is a moody guy, but he will believe him if John believes Todd’s story about Heather’s murder. John believes Todd and asks for more details. Todd heard Caleb tell Heather that with the baby it would be easy to get the mother to come with him. John remembers what Lucy said, that Caleb was obsessed with Livvie. She was the reason he did everything. He realizes Caleb was using Danny as bait to get to Sam and yells for the guard to let him out. Just then Anna and Alexis come in and he immediately knows something is wrong. Anna tells them Sam and the baby are gone.
Tomorrow’s Port Charles spoilers for General Hospital:
Rafe blames himself.
Lucy tells Molly to break Rafe out of prison.
Tracy wonders why she would give AJ anything when he will just stab her in the back.
Join Soaps.com on Twitter @soapoperafan, "like" Soaps.com on Facebook to dish on "General Hospital," all the other soap operas, "Dallas," "Glee," "Grey’s Anatomy," "Vampire Diaries," "Revenge," "Pretty Little Liars," and "Venice The Series."