Quote Rickyp30: So if you think about it. Gabi was responsible for the explosion that killed JJ and Abigail's dad she could be brought up on charges so I do agree Sonny could of used that against Nick. Unless he couldn't due to the fact he would be endangering chad for telling him that and chad would go to jail that would be the only reason I can see Sonny not telling
Yes, Sonny is supposedly protecting CHAD his partner and good friend. But I do not think Will would hurt Chad. I think will would keep the secret, too.
Agreed - I also think that Will deserves to know the truth about the mother of his child. It is up to Will to decide what he wants to do with the information. Of course, Will would not do anything to hurt Chad; and he will not turn Gabi into the police. But, he still deserves to know the truth.
Will DESERVES to know the truth no matter what I think. Sonny is the one who has continuously insisted on no secrets all the while he has kept this one.
Will had asked Sonny repeatedly why he did not like Gabi and what did Gabi do. If Will were keeping this a secret from Sonny he would be severely criticized.
Will is so forgiving. He would forgive Gabi. He would never get Chad in trouble. Never. So what is Sonny's justification in keeping this secret?
It makes no sense not to trust him. None.
There has to be another reason writers do this.
So while I think the story line portrayed sonny as so very perfect at the beginning and we felt for him when Will was struggling and he was pining for him; they then made Sonny more realistic with flaws in his character.
And that is a good thing because we do not want one perfect person and one flawed!' (Although they are both pretty close to perfect)
It surprises me that some people think this is a non issue and that Sonny is correct in keeping the secret and continuously point out Wills insecurities and Say "they promised no secrets and will is not telling about his insecurity so he is keeping a secret!" And I read that over and over mainly on other places or YouTube. But I'm thinking his secret is so minor in that he's worried his boyfriend is giving up something whereas Sonny is keeping a huge secret that could have changed everything with blackmail.
Get this: !!!!!!!!
If Sonny had used this secret to stop Nick, then Sami would have never gone after that evidence. No video would exist Will would not be at risk now! Sami would not be in jail!
This is a huge secret. sonny is wrong here.
I agree that Will should be told this secret. I know that technically it is Chad's secret to tell, but Sonny knows it and Will knows Sonny is not telling him something about Gabi. But for some reason this secret is being kept from Will and it DRIVES ME CRAZY. Sonny is so adamant about not keeping secrets from each other. But yet this is A BIG SECRET that Sonny is keeping from Will.