When Brady and Kristen wake up in her bed together after sex, Kristen jumps in shock. He has to go! What they did was almost biblically wrong. He disagrees. She calls their attraction more like a friction. He hates her! He changed his mind and is sorry she's so overwhelmed. She admits she has feelings for him but was never going to act on them because of her past with John. She asks Brady to keep this a secret. He leaves and Kristen makes a call to John. "I need to see you. Now."
At the cafe, Marlena flashes to her break and entry into Kristen's hotel room. She has to discuss something with him. He sighs and wonders if it's about Kristen. He leaves and a lipstick falls from his jacket. Kate arrives and shares the news about her divorce. Marlena knows she put a lot into that marriage and loved Stefano. Kate sees the lipstick and confirms it's the new CW prototype. Sami and Kristen are two of the few who would have a tube. Billie arrives. She just saw John at the Salem Inn. Marlena runs off and stares at the lipstick thinking Kristen played her for the last time. Inside, Billie's sorry Kate's hurting though she thinks the divorce is for the best.
In her office, Sami stares at the flowers Rafe gave her and calls him. EJ cuts her off with work. When Rafe returns her call she ignores it and takes off with EJ to the rectory.
At the rectory, Nicole is busy at work on her first day. She jokes about her conservative attire and sleeping in a twin bed for the first time since she was nine. She slept like a rock. Eric flashes to his nightmares. He brushes off her concerns that they may lose donations for the school if people learn she works there.
At the pub, Will tells Gabi he hasn't made a decision yet. Rafe interrupts after hearing Gabi talk about what a difficult decision this is. Why is Will in the center of this again? Will wanders off and Gabi reminds her brother that Will's her best friend. He's being unfair. Gabi admits it was nice to see him with Sami. He should probably make a move. Rafe grins. It's complicated. He leaves and Will returns. Will thinks it's wrong to lie to his son his whole life the way he was lied to. Gabi thinks there are thousands of reasons why they can't raise the kid together. They think if they tell the truth they could lose the men they love.
Sami introduces EJ to Eric at the rectory. EJ hands over a check that Kristen forgot. Sami's pissed that Nicole's working there. Has Eric lost his mind? Sami kicks everyone out and berates her brother. She can't believe he took Nicole in after what she did to her. Eric calls her on being a hypocrite. Sami accuses Eric of having poor judgement so he reminds her she's working with EJ. She's been making lousy judgements since she was three. Sami wants Eric to get along with EJ, her boss and the father of her kids.
In the square, Nicole watches as EJ laughs in her face about her new job at the rectory. How can she live there with her voracious sexual appetite? She tells him, "You sure are talking a lot of smack." It's not like she's becoming a nun. She just wants to become a better person. If she doesn't make these changes now she never will. EJ thinks she's hardwired to have self-destructive ways. She looks pointedly at him and brings up him going after Sami. He can't compete with Rafe because he and Sami share a "real love."
John turns up on Kristen's doorstep at Salem Inn. Later, Marlena hears moaning outside the door and opens it...
Back at the rectory, Eric reminds Sami of the Sydnapping. She knows about the terrible things EJ did but he has changed. Nicole walks up and hears Eric defending her. Sami leaves and Eric reassures Nicole that he knows what he's doing.
Sami finds EJ at the square. She rants about Nicole ruining her brother's life but EJ won't let it happen. She calms down and laughs just as Rafe spots them.
Sami and EJ enjoy working together, but Sami is pulled towards Rafe.
Sonny believes Nick and Gabi's marriage is the secret Will's been keeping.