Together at the pub, John tells Marlena he ran into Kristen at Sami's office last night. Marlena says Kristen already told her. Marlena accuses John of working out his story with Kristen and immediately apologizes. Kayla interrupts and John rushes for a meeting at the rectory. Marlena spaces out and they discuss Caroline's treatment. She's doing well and fed the sea lions in Monterey. Marlena dishes on the issues with Kristen's return and Kayla reminds her she's a psychiatrist. Kristen's deliberately pushing her buttons. Marlena agrees. "I think she's trying to make me look like an irrational shrew and I took the bait."
On the phone with Stefano from her room, Kristen refuses to move into the mansion which she says is full of ghosts. She confirms she received the box from Mary and both cryptically discuss never forgetting anything. Kristen opens the box and finds a cassette. "Milli Vanilli." She finds a video cassette of John Jr.'s first bath, and a key. She heads out.
Victor stops Brady at the Kiriakis mansion, looking for help in saving Daniel's soul and has an idea which includes Brady throwing himself at Nicole. Brady rubs his hand over his face and shakes his head. Victor thinks his net worth will turn Nicole's head away from Daniel. Brady's disgusted. He's not toying with her head. They argue.
From his office at the hospital, Daniel is in shock as he flashes hearing Nicole knew her baby was dead before the fall. Cameron interrupts. Daniel says it's possible the baby died before the trauma of Nicole's fall. Daniel asks him to keep it to himself. Maxine calls him over to talk with Dr. Sedwick on the phone. She emails him details about Nicole's appointment.
Jennifer is unwelcome when she arrives on Daniel's doorstep to chat with Nicole. Jenn thanks her for not charging her with murder and accuses her of erasing a message for Daniel. That's how she knew Jenn was at the square... Nicole admits she went there to confront her and tell her she hates her guts. They argue about Nicole making a deal with Daniel in order to keep Jenn out of jail. Jenn storms off and Nicole becomes stressed. She fantasizes of Jennifer bursting her bubble with Daniel and hyperventilates. She calls but he ignores her call.
Father Tobias meets with John at the rectory. The board meeting is cancelled. In walks Kristen, the newest member. Things are awkward. Kristen's taking Stefano's place while he's away. Father Tobias leaves the room and Kristen admits she isn't surprised to see him here. She flashes to talking to John about defeating the demon in Marlena. He's still the most caring man she knows. She leaves and the men speak of forgiveness and people changing.
From Daniel's, Nicole calls around looking for Daniel. Brady calls.
Back at the hospital, Daniel takes a call from Sedwick and thanks her for her clear notes. He knows exactly what happened that day. He holds the baby clothes and hands them over to Cameron to return them to the lost and found.
John bumps into Marlena at the square. He tells her his meeting was cancelled but he saw Kristen there. Marlena remembers Kristen was always working with the church while she was lying and scheming.
Kristen heads to her room and fondles the key she found while flashing to a date on the beach with John from years gone by.
Back at Victor's, he blows up at Brady upon hearing that Nicole didn't answer his call. He waited too long.
Daniel heads home to an empty apartment.
Nicole pounds on Jenn's door and looks for her spare key. She finds the scalpel as Jenn answers the door.