Quote bethonly: even if brooke chose Katie, she would always have it thrown in her face that brooke stole katies husband. just like Katie saying that brooke was the sl@t from the valley. I don't think that relationship is salvageable. she should go with the one she loves and stay with the one who will always love her back. let's face it, even if Katie got bill back, it would always be out of pity and for his sons sake.
It's a bit optimistic putting the words Brooke and always in the same sentence when it is about Brooke's sexual relationship.
Bill/Katie is a relationship that is not salvageable as it was with Katie so trusting and vulnerable and Bill so self opinionated. They could forge a new relationship based on a more adult couple who have learned from this and it could be better than the old.
But... Brooke will never, never, never, let that happen. Brooke never lets go. She holds old flames with tears and yapping about what they once had. She lets them know they owe her. She pulls out the pity card like she did when trying to get Eric to be the baby's dad. Her full on indulgence with sex is something they don't forget. It seemed so real and unconditional at the time. She seemed to love them so completely and what man can forget a woman who just seemed determined to fulfil his every desire? Let's face it - What woman would ever forget a man who did that for her?
So unless Bill can see that Brooke never backed off to let his marriage with Katie work - and Brooke didn't. She talked the talk all the time enticing him with secret looks, suggestive poses, subtle undermining of Katie's womanhood etc. Unless Bill returns honestly to his previous vision of Brooke and completely rejects her and is horrified at what they did - then he and Katie will never work. Brooke never goes away. She keeps past relationships in the males faces until she needs them. She keeps them infected. It's not love they feel it's obsession and its sick and ugly.