JR continues to yell with exhaustion for Babe! Babe! He looks on at Jamie proclaiming that Jamie would rather he bag the search for his wife. But he refuses, still yelling he spots something in the water. JR gasps oh no and jumps into the water. Jamie screams after JR to get back in the boat and starts to undress to go in after him.
Julia and Jamie pull JR into the boat, unconscious and not breathing. After several minutes of panic, they revive him. JR, shivering and breathless, insists he'll find his wife alive. Jamie tells him to rest, that he'll keep a lookout all night, he promises JR. If Jamie finds anything, he'll wake JR immediately.
Julia lays out a bed on the bench for JR. She gets him warm and comfortable and assures him they'll keep looking.
Jamie looks on at Julia after JR falls into a restless sleep. Shaking his head, he smartly asks her how lucky she is to have this kind of night. Julia replies, "Pretty lucky."
JR dreams they recovered Josh and got him on the boat alive. "She's dead JR," says Josh. "Dead." Josh goes on to JR, "Just like you lost your mother, Babe is dead too. You don't deserve anyone JR."
Julia, noticing JR wincing, startles him awake, telling him the coast guard found a little island.